From 29a47cd7fef82027d6fe750c49108289fb819e4b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Ivana Date: Wed, 28 Sep 2022 10:59:23 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Update messages uploaded Y knows x has mb --- messages-uploaded-Y-knows-x-has-mb.md | 58 +++++++++++++-------------- 1 file changed, 29 insertions(+), 29 deletions(-) diff --git a/messages-uploaded-Y-knows-x-has-mb.md b/messages-uploaded-Y-knows-x-has-mb.md index 23d8bbc..28cb7ad 100644 --- a/messages-uploaded-Y-knows-x-has-mb.md +++ b/messages-uploaded-Y-knows-x-has-mb.md @@ -14,68 +14,68 @@ The expected results are defined here Scenarios: -When X has a mailbox, but Y doesn't yet know about X's mailbox: +When X has a mailbox, and Y knows about X's mailbox: * X will upload messages and acks for Y to X's mailbox +* Y will upload messages and acks for X to X's mailbox * X will check X's mailbox for messages and acks uploaded by Y -* Y won't upload anything to X's mailbox, or download anything from it, as Y doesn't yet know about X's mailbox -* Communication via X's mailbox won't work in either direction -* This problem will resolve itself when Y receives X's update informing Y about X's mailbox, which will happen the next time X and Y are online at the same time +* Y will check X's mailbox for messages and acks uploaded by X +* Communication via X's mailbox will work in both directions -### Scenario 2: X has a mailbox that Y doesn't know about +### Scenario 3: X has a mailbox that Y knows about -In this scenario, X and Y become contacts and then Y goes offline. While Y is offline, X links a mailbox (M). Y doesn't know about X's mailbox, because no connection has happened between X and Y since X linked the mailbox. +In this scenario, X and Y become contacts and then X links a mailbox (M) while Y is online. Y learns about X's mailbox, because there has been a connection between X and Y since X linked the mailbox. Then Y goes offline. -While Y is offline, X writes a message to Y. X's message is uploaded to X's mailbox (one tick). Then X goes offline and Y comes back online. Y doesn't download X's message from X's mailbox because Y doesn't know about the mailbox yet. +While Y is offline, X writes a message to Y. X's message is uploaded to X's mailbox (one tick). Then X goes offline and Y comes back online. Y knows about X's mailbox, so Y downloads X's message from the mailbox. -While X is offline, Y writes a message to X. Y's message is not uploaded to X's mailbox (clock icon), because Y doesn't know about the mailbox yet. Then X comes back online. +While X is offline, Y writes a message to X. Y knows about X's mailbox so Y's message is uploaded to X's mailbox (one tick), along with an ack for X's message. Then Y goes offline and X comes back online. X downloads Y's message and the ack for X's message from X's mailbox. X's message is shown as sent and acked (two ticks). X uploads an ack for Y's message to X's mailbox. Then X goes offline and Y comes back online. -When X and Y are online at the same time, both messages are sent and acked (two ticks). +While X is offline, Y downloads the ack for Y's message from X's mailbox. Y's message is shown as sent and acked (two ticks). -* Install Briar on X and Y +[] Install Briar on X and Y * Add X and Y as contacts * In Briar's connection settings, turn off wifi and Bluetooth connections on X and Y -* Take Y offline * Install Mailbox on M * Link Briar running on X with Mailbox running on M +* Wait a few seconds for X's update informing Y about X's mailbox to be delivered to Y +* Take Y offline * X writes a message to Y * Expectation: the message is shown as sent (one tick) in X's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for X to connect to M and upload the message) * Take X offline * Bring Y back online * Expectation: X is shown as offline in Y's contact list -* Expectation: X's message does not appear in Y's conversation screen -* Y writes a message to X -* Expectation: Y's message is shown as not sent (clock icon) in Y's conversation screen -* While keeping Y online, bring X back online -* Expectation: X is shown as online in Y's contact list and vice versa (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for X and Y to connect to each other) -* Expectation: X's message appears in Y's conversation screen -* Expectation: X's message is shown as sent and acked (two ticks) in X's conversation screen -* Expectation: Y's message appears in X's conversation screen -* Expectation: Y's message is shown as sent and acked in Y's conversation screen +* Expectation: X's message appears in Y's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for Y to connect to M and download the message) +* While X is still offline, Y writes a message to X +* Expectation: Y's message is shown as sent (one tick) in Y's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for Y to connect to M and upload the message) +* Take Y offline +* Bring X back online +* Expecation: Y is shown as offline in X's contact list +* Expectation: Y's message appears in X's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for X to connect to M and download the message) +* Expectation: X's message is shown as sent and acked (two ticks) in X's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for X to connect to M and download the ack) +* Take X offline +* Bring Y back online +* Expectation: X is shown as offline in Y's contact list +* Expectation: Y's message is shown as sent and acked (two ticks) in Y's conversation screen (after a delay of up to 2 minutes for Y to connect to M and download the ack) Executed with the following devices and versions of software -* Briar build 34815eb1a51d3aac2f0978d0066c694c963afc3b +* Briar build dd3a9aa71ba44293be2c05e853c5cb652ce6bf67 * Mailbox build fe5453902347ef7ee91e24b373d340e6a9921f12 Devices: -1. Samsung Mini 9195 Android 4.4.2 Briar (X) Pixel 2 Android 11 Briar (Y) Nokia 3.2 Android 10 Mailbox +1. Samsung Mini 9195 Android 4.4.2 Briar (X) Samsung A01S Core Android 10 Briar (Y) HTC One M9 Android 7 (M) -= OK += -Executed with the following devices and versions of software -* Briar build 04011e50bc92f4c220187c93dc7330fae2cb96c9 -* Mailbox build fe5453902347ef7ee91e24b373d340e6a9921f12 - -1. +2. HTC One m9 Android 7 (x) Samsung Core A01s Android 10 (y) Motorola E2 Android 6 (M) = OK -1. Huawei CDY NX9A Android 10 (X) XIAOMI Mi 11 Lite 5G Android 11 (Y) Samsung 6810 S Android 4.1.2 (M) +3. Huawei CDY NX9A Android 10 (X) XIAOMI Mi 11 Lite 5G Android 11 (Y) Samsung 6810 S Android 4.1.2 (M) = OK